European recyclers have backed an EU committee’s proposal to prevent the so-called mass balance method for chemical recycling, following concerns that mechanical recyclers would face unfair competition.
The European Parliament’s Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety (ENVI) voted through German MEP Jutta Paulus’ proposal to prevent mass balance being used under the Single-Use Plastics Directive.
The committee’s rationale was to promote mechanical recycling over technologies such as pyrolysis. Recycling trade bodies fear the mass balance approach would give plastics-to-oil firms an unfair advantage in accessing feedstock.
The ENVI vote now threatens this legislation and a further round of voting will take place next week.
Paulus’ motion argued that the “unstated rationale” for mass balance was to promote chemical recycling over energy recovery. She added that mechanical recycling “is indeed preferable to chemical recycling, in particular when compared to pyrolysis and gasification, as it requires less energy and therefore creates significantly less CO2”.
Paulus said mechanical recycling has created 30,000 jobs in 850 companies across Europe. European waste management association FEAD has warned that diversion of plastic waste to “a few chemical recycling plants” would put businesses at risk.
FEAD, along with recycling trade body EuRIC, Zero Waste Europe (ZWE) and seven other trade groups, backed the committee’s vote.
A joint position statement said mass balance would “create an unlevel playing field between recycling technologies” and “keep consumers from taking sustainable purchasing decisions due to structural greenwashing”.
It added: “While we support the complementarity of chemical and mechanical recycling technologies, priority should be given to mechanical recycling for waste streams, including PET, that can be recycled mechanically with a lower environmental footprint.”
Lauriane Veillard, ZWE policy officer, said: “This is a call to redefine the pecking order of technologies, ensuring that the recycled plastics hitting our markets are not only safe and transparent but also fair.”
Under the EU’s Packaging and Packaging Waste Directive, plastic drinks bottles will require at least 30% recycled content from 2030.
Fuente: Materials Recycling World